If p and q are integers and p + q + p is odd, which of the following must be odd?
View explanation
Correct answer: B
Since the product of an even number and any other integer will always be even, the value of \(2p\) must be even. If \(q\) were even, \(2p + q\) would be the sum of two even integers and would thus have to be even. But the problem stem tells us that \(2p + q\) is odd. Therefore, \(q\) cannot be even, and must be odd.
Alternatively, we can reach this same conclusion by testing numbers. We simply test even and odd values of \(p\) and \(q\) to see whether they meet our condition that \(p + q + p\) must be odd.
1) even + even + even = even (for example, \(4 + 2 + 4 = 10\)). The combination (\(p\) even, \(q\) even) does not meet our condition.
2) odd + odd + odd = odd (for example, \(5 + 3 + 5 = 13\)). The combination (\(p\) odd, \(q\) odd) does meet our condition.
3) even + odd + even = odd (for example, \(4 + 3 + 4 = 11\)). The combination (\(p\) even, \(q\) odd) does meet our condition.
4) odd + even + odd = even (for example, \(3 + 4 + 3 = 10\)). The combination (\(p\) odd, \(q\) even) does not meet our condition.
If we examine our results, we see that \(q\) has to be odd, while \(p\) can be either odd or even. Our question asks us which answer must be odd; since \(q\) is an answer choice, we don't have to test the more complicated answer choices.
The correct answer is B.