If p and q are integers and p + q + p is odd, which of the following must be odd?
View explanation
Correct answer: B
First, let us simplify the original expression: \(p + q + p = 2p + q\)<br><br>
Since the product of an even number and any other integer will always be even, the value of \(2p\) must be even. If \(q\) were even, \(2p + q\) would be the sum of two even integers and would thus have to be even. But the problem stem tells us that \(2p + q\) is odd. Therefore, \(q\) cannot be even, and must be odd.<br><br>
Alternatively, we can reach this same conclusion by testing numbers. We simply test even and odd values of \(p\) and \(q\) to see whether they meet our condition that \(p + q + p\) must be odd.<br><br>
1) even + even + even = even (for example, \(4 + 2 + 4 = 10\)). The combination (\(p\) even, \(q\) even) does not meet our condition.<br><br>
2) odd + odd + odd = odd (for example, \(5 + 3 + 5 = 13\)). The combination (\(p\) odd, \(q\) odd) does meet our condition.<br><br>
3) even + odd + even = odd (for example, \(4 + 3 + 4 = 11\)). The combination (\(p\) even, \(q\) odd) does meet our condition.<br><br>
4) odd + even + odd = even (for example, \(3 + 4 + 3 = 10\)). The combination (\(p\) odd, \(q\) even) does not meet our condition.<br><br>
If we examine our results, we see that \(q\) has to be odd, while \(p\) can be either odd or even. Our question asks us which answer must be odd; since \(q\) is an answer choice, we don't have to test the more complicated answer choices.<br><br>
The correct answer is B.